Imagine a learner who can explain a science experiment clearly in conversation but spends most of the lesson struggling to write a formal report. If the lesson is about interpreting evidence, the report may be obscuring the skill the teacher wants to see. If the lesson is about writing scientific reports, the format belongs in the goal. A meaningful learning goal makes that distinction explicit.
Name the learning before choosing the assignment

CAST’s Universal Design for Learning guidelines ask educators to set meaningful goals and, where possible, separate the learning goal from the means used to achieve it. Start with what learners should be able to explain, create, or do. Then identify the evidence needed to judge it. A written answer, recorded explanation, or annotated diagram may each show the same reasoning when writing itself is outside the scope of the assessment. [1] [2]
Consider the difference between “submit a five-slide presentation about renewable energy” and “compare two energy sources using evidence about reliability and environmental impact.” The presentation is a possible format. The comparison is the learning. A teacher can require the evidence in both formats and allow students to use whichever medium lets them show their reasoning clearly. If designing a presentation is itself the target skill, the format is now a legitimate part of the task.
Write criteria a learner can apply to their own work
A criterion is useful when someone can check it before asking for a grade. For the energy example, give students three questions. Did I compare the sources on the same criteria? Did I use relevant evidence for each? Did I explain one trade-off in my recommendation? Look at one sample answer together and point to the sentence, data point, or diagram that meets each criterion.
In a workplace, the same approach applies when someone is learning to review a project brief. “Read five examples” describes an activity. “Identify the decision, the available evidence, and the main unresolved assumption in a new brief” describes something a colleague can observe. The learner can annotate a document or explain their review aloud. The supervisor uses the same criteria whichever format is chosen.
Keep the challenge and adjust the support
Check whether a learner is struggling with the target skill or a barrier around the task. If a student can compare sources once they have access to the data, improve access. If they can read the data but draw conclusions from only one source, model a comparison and provide another opportunity to practise it. A scaffold can be a worked example, a vocabulary sheet, or a question prompt. Plan when to remove it if independent performance is part of the goal.
A good baseline helps you choose the next challenge. Ask the learner to try a short version of the task before the first lesson. A student who can already cite relevant evidence may need practice interpreting conflicting evidence. A student who cannot find usable evidence may first need a smaller, explicit objective. Both can work toward the same longer-term skill with different support.
Use feedback to plan the next attempt
John Hattie and Helen Timperley describe feedback in terms of the intended goal, current progress, and what to do next. They also distinguish feedback about the work and the process from general comments about the person. CAST’s guidance calls for feedback that gives learners a way to act. “Great job” may feel encouraging. “You compared the costs clearly. Now use the same time period for both emissions estimates” gives the learner a revision they can make. [3] [4]
Leave room in the schedule for that revision. In the example, the learner could explain the trade-off a second time using comparable data. A short follow-up task with two different energy sources can check whether the reasoning transfers. Each attempt should answer a question about the skill. There is little value in producing another full presentation when a paragraph or diagram will show whether the learner can use the feedback.
A goal you can use as a model
By the end of the unit, compare two energy sources for a specific community, using evidence about reliability and environmental impact. Recommend one option and explain a trade-off. Show the reasoning in an annotated chart, a brief recording, or a written explanation.
- First attempt. Compare two sample sources and highlight which facts support each claim.
- Support. Offer a worked comparison and a shared list of terms. Let learners request a prompt if they get stuck.
- Review. Point to one criterion the work meets and one specific revision. Give time for a second attempt.
- Transfer. Try the same reasoning with a new set of sources and check whether the comparison still holds.
For more on choosing a goal when you are still learning the method, see the guide to choosing and revising goals.
References
- CAST (2024). Set meaningful goals. UDL Guidelines, consideration 6.1.
- CAST. Teaching and learning. UDL Schoolwide Implementation Criteria.
- Hattie & Timperley (2007). The power of feedback.
- CAST (2024). Offer action-oriented feedback. UDL Guidelines, consideration 8.5.
Further reading
Read the original guide from CAST UDL Guidelines.

